A reader takes exception to a debunking story:

The New York Times
June 19, 1982
Section 1, Page 24

On the Incidence of Alligators and Hard Times

Richard Mock linocut
Linocut by Richard Mock

To the Editor:

Anna Quindlen's May 19 news story "Debunking the Myth of Subterranean Saurians" did a great disservice to true believers. John Flaherty (Chief of design in the New York City Bureau of Sewers), whom she quotes, professes that "there are no alligators in the New York City sewer system." I protest!

No less a source than "All the News That's Fit to Print" reported a veritable rash of "saurian sightings" in the city sewers through the 1930's. Our research on this subject is limited, because, in truth, we were looking for giraffes. The alligators were serendipitous.

At any rate, we refer Miss Quindlen and Mr. Flaherty to The Times for Feb. 10, 1935, which reports a brave lad, Salvatore Condulucci, and his friends attacking an eight-foot alligator with snow shovels on East 123d Street. Some other reports that appeared in The Times:

June 30, 1932 - alligators in the Bronx River; Sept. 12, 1932 - alligators in New Jersey; June 1, 1937 - alligators in the East River; June 7, 1937 - alligators in the Brooklyn subway!

As I have suggested in our newsletter, Coastlines, there may be a relationship between economic hard times and an outpouring of alligators, as evidenced by the reports in The Times. Perhaps Mr. Flaherty should become prepared.

Director, New York Sea Grant Institute
Albany, June 4, 1982

John T. Flaherty responds